League Champions
| YEAR | REGULAR SEASON CHAMPIONS | POST-SEASON CHAMPIONS |
| 2024 | Indiana University of PA | Indiana University of PA |
| 2023 | Indiana University of PA | Indiana University of PA |
| 2022 | University of Pittsburgh | John Carroll University |
| 2021 | Robert Morris University | Robert Morris University |
| 2020 | University of Pittsburgh | Indiana University of PA |
| 2019 | Indiana University of PA | Robert Morris University |
| 2018 | University of Pittsburgh | John Carroll University |
| 2017 | University of Pittsburgh | John Carroll University |
| 2016 | Mercyhurst University | University of Pittsburgh |
| 2015 | Robert Morris University | Robert Morris University |
| 2014 | West Virginia University | West Virginia University |
| 2013 | John Carroll University | Mercyhurst University |
| 2012 | West Virginia University | West Virginia University |
| 2011 | Slippery Rock University | Slippery Rock University |
| 2010 | Slippery Rock University | West Virginia University |
| 2009 | Duquesne University | Duquesne University |
| 2008 | West Virginia University | Washington & Jefferson College |
| 2007 | Washington & Jefferson College | Duquesne University |
