2020: Stu Rulnick, Pittsburgh
2019: Conrad Waite, Duquesne
2018: Stu Rulnick, Pittsburgh
2017: Conrad Waite, Duquesne
2016: Stu Rulnick, Pittsburgh
2015: Mike Joseph, Robert Morris
2014: Stu Rulnick, Pittsburgh; Paul Taibi, West Virginia
2013: Christian Wilk, John Carroll
2012: Christian Wilk, John Carroll
2011: Zach Sonnefeld, West Virginia
2010: Bill Waldschmidt, Slippery Rock
2009: Dan Hestin, Indiana U of PA
2008:
2007:
