2005 Mike Janela, Syracuse
Jamison Coyle, Syracuse
2006 Kyle Stinson, Gonzaga
Jon Billings, Gonzaga
2007 Ben Youngerman, Syracuse
Greg Morrison, Syracuse
2008 Dale Long, Indiana State
Aaron Watson, Indiana State
2009 Andrew Africk, Syracuse
Jon Irwin, Syracuse
2010 Kevin Brown, Syracuse
Tim Bickford, Syracuse
2011 Matthew Dudas, Millersville University
Michael Broskowski, Western Illinois
2012 Mario Gonzalez, Illinois
Brian Siegel, Illinois
2013 Kyle Breitbarth, Illinois
Kyle Milnamow, Illinois
2014 Austin Pollack, Syracuse University
Emma Tiedemann, University of Missouri
2015 Kyle Howard, Bowling Green State University
Kevin Piel, Bowling Green State University
2016 Josh Grissom, University of Idaho
Dan Collins, University of Illinois
Jordan Swick, Bowling Green University
2017 Hunter Warning, University of Illinois
Troy Wisneski, Florida State University
2018 Connor Mills, Ohio University
Bradley Walker, Ohio University
2019 Nick Viland, Ohio University
Brandon Monty, Ohio University
2021 Reese Lannon, Bowling Green
Sean Nief, Indiana University
2022 Trey Yanity, University of Alabama
Howie Boxley, University of Alabama
2023 Austin Barach, Syracuse University
Jesse Cook, Syracuse University
2024 Charles Fellows, Syracuse University
Dylan Simmons, Middle Tennessee State
